Moneyballing the Polaris Prize long list

Amelia Curran should have
been on the 2015 long list

Here it is, folks, your 2015 Polaris Music Prize long list. 196 critics voted for 197 titles, and we wound up with these 40. Some kings went down for a fall. Some obscure underdogs are now part of the conversation. Ten will be on the short list, announced July 16, and one will be given $50,000 on Sept. 21. (The other nine artists on the short list get $3,000 each.)

Absolutely Free – s/t 

The Acorn – Vieux Loup

Lydia Ainsworth – Right From Real

Alvvays – s/t

Arkells – High Noon

Rich Aucoin – Ephemeral

BadBadNotGood feat. Ghostface Killah – Sour Soul

Bahamas – Is Afie

Barr Brothers - Sleeping Operator

Braids – Deep in the Iris

Steph Cameron – Sad-Eyed Lonesome Lady

Caribou – Our Love

Jazz Cartier – Marauding in Paradise

Jennifer Castle – Pink City

Cold Specks – Neuroplasticity

Louis-Jean Cormier – Les Grandes Arteres

Death From Above 1979 – The Physical World

Drake – If You’re Reading This, It’s Too Late

Frazey Ford – Indian Ocean

Tobias Jesso Jr. – Goon

B.A. Johnston – Shit Sucks

Pierre Kwenders – Le dernier empereur bantou

Lee Harvey Osmond – Beautiful Scars

Jean Leloup – A Paradis City

Metz – II

Milk and Bone – Little Morning  

Tre Mission – Stigmata

New Pornographers – Brill Bruisers

Joel Plaskett – Park Avenue Sobriety Test

Buffy Sainte-Marie – Power in the Blood

Elizabeth Shepherd – The Signal

Siskiyou – Nervous

Colin Stetson and Sarah Neufeld – Never the Way She Was

Various Artists – Native North America

Viet Cong – s/t

Patrick Watson – Love Songs for Robots

Weather Station – Loyalty

White Lung – Deep Fantasy

Whitehorse – Leave No Bridge Unburned

Young Guv – Ripe 4 Luv

I wrote about some trends in this list for Maclean's today as well, and make the case for 74-year-old Buffy Sainte-Marie having a good shot at being the oldest winner in the history of Polaris—which usually has a Logan's Run policy at age 40.

Familiar faces

Previous winners: 2 (Caribou, Patrick Watson)

Previous shortlisters: 9

Previous longlisters: 8

New to Polaris: 21

Compilations: 1 (first time that’s happened)

Most appearances on Polaris list: Patrick Watson, Joel Plaskett and New Pornographers are all making their fourth appearance on a Polaris list. [updated] Tom Wilson's main project, Lee Harvey Osmond, has now made three long lists; his other band, Blackie and the Rodeo Kings, has also longlisted, meaning he too has been on four times.

Geography

Toronto: 16

Montreal: 6

Vancouver: 5

Hamilton: 4 (Arkells, Caribou, Lee Harvey Osmond, B.A. Johnston)

Halifax: 2 (Rich Aucoin, Joel Plaskett) (also Alvvays)

Quebec City: 1

Ottawa: 1 (The Acorn)

Calgary: 1

Rural B.C.: 1 (Steph Cameron)
Hawaii via Saskatchewan: 1 (Buffy Sainte-Marie)

West of Ontario: 7

East of Quebec: 2

Babies and geezers

Debut albums: 7

Oldest performers: Buffy Sainte-Marie, 74; [updated] Tom Wilson (Lee Harvey Osmond), 55; Jean Leloup, 54; A.C. Newman (New Pornographers), 47; Ghostface Killah, 45

Genre

Hip-hop: 4 (Drake, BadBadNotGood, Jazz Cartier, Tre Mission)

Francophone: 3 (Louis-Jean Cormier, Pierre Kwenders, Jean Leloup)

Experimental: 2 (Absolutely Free, Colin Stetson and Sarah Neufeld)

Electronic: 2 (Rich Aucoin, Caribou)

Aggressive: 2 (White Lung, Metz)

Jazz: 1 (Elizabeth Shepherd)

World: 1 (Pierre Kwenders, though arguably electronic)

Everything else (rock, pop, folk, roots): 25

The ladies

Female-fronted bands or solo acts: 14

Bands not fronted by women but with female instrumentalists: 1 (New Pornographers) (Note: there are only 14 acts on the list that could be considered bands, not solo acts or duos)

Heroes to zeroes

Previous winners left off the 2015 long list:

Godspeed You Black Emperor (abstained) (winner, 2013)

Tagaq (winner, 2014): She didn't release an album of her own material, but her 2015 album with the Kronos Quartet, Tundra Songs, featured compositions by Derek Charke.

Fucked Up (winner 2008, shortlist 2012)

Previous shortlisters left off the 2015 long list:

Purity Ring (shortlisted, 2013) 

Galaxie (shortlisted 2011)

Ron Sexsmith (shortlisted 2011) Previous album didn’t longlist either

Hey Rosetta (shortlisted 2009, 2011)

Stars (shortlisted 2008, longlisted 2011) Previous album didn’t longlist either

Elliott Brood (shortlisted 2009) Previous album didn’t longlist either

Great Lake Swimmers (shortlisted 2009, longlisted 2012)

Dan Mangan (shortlisted, 2010, longlisted 2012)

And these artists, though they’ve never made the shortlist, have long-listed more than once—but not this year:

Leonard Cohen (longlisted 2009, 2012) 

Buck 65 (longlisted 2008, 2011)

Hayden (longlisted 2008, 2013)

Sloan (longlisted 2009, 2011)

Juno winners, Polaris losers:

Magic! (Single of the Year, Breakthrough Group of the Year)

Nickelback (new album not eligible at last Junos, but multiple winner over the years)

Kiesza (Dance Recording of the Year)

Lights (Pop Album of the Year)

Deadmau5 (Electronic Album of the Year)

Catherine MacLellan    (Roots and Traditional – Solo)

Devin Townsend Project (Metal Album of the Year) 

So who was robbed? I thought these would surely be on the list:

Amelia Curran

Rochelle Jordan

Kiesza

Mo Kenney

Terra Lightfoot

And then some albums I was considering (and/or voted for), but wasn’t sure if they’d make it:

Afiara Quartet + Skratch Bastid

Boogat

Leonard Cohen

Ian William Craig

Iceberg Ferg

Keita Juma

Daniel Lanois
Last Ex

Salomé Leclerc

Sagot

I’ll elaborate more on those in a later post.

In the meantime, I urge you to give these all a spin.

FFS

FFS – s/t (Domino)

Two bands, Scotland’s Franz Ferdinand and L.A.’s Sparks, separated by three generations of pop music, join forces to create a new band, in which they insist both camps are equal partners. This is not just the rock band backing up Sparks’s Mael brothers, who have spent the last 10 years ditching all rock instruments and writing arch satire set to orchestrally arranged synths. Well aware of the inherent pitfalls at work, this sarcastic bunch was confident enough to write a song called “Collaborations Don’t Work”—and prove themselves wrong in the process. There’s another song here called “Save Me From Myself”: apt, as FFS brings out the best in both acts.

Sparks’s discography is so extensive (23 and counting) that it’s hard to know where to dive into their bizarro rabbit hole, though 1974’s Kimono My House and their late-’70s albums with Giorgio Moroder are a good start. Otherwise you’ll end up picking titles based on their punny titles, the best being 1994’s Gratuitous Sax and Senseless Violins.

FFS, however, is an ideal introduction: the presence of concise collaborators reins in Sparks’s more repetitive and/or outré ideas—but rest assured that all their idiosyncrasies intact. For starters, there’s not only one, but two references to Jean-Paul Sartre here: with correct French pronunciation, no less.

The project dates back 10 years, when Franz Ferdinand were riding high on the strength of their first album. Word of their appreciation for Sparks got back to veteran duo, and a meeting was arranged around a tour stop in L.A. Talk of collaboration ensured and some demos were exchanged, but the idea lay dormant until another chance encounter at Coachella last year. Songs were written, rehearsed and then recorded live by the end of the year.

FFS was formed in order to build perfect pop hooks around lyrics like “Some might find me borderline attractive from afar” or singing a litany of “Things I Won’t Get” (“A chair that’s designed by Charles and Ray Eames”), and it succeeds wildly. For fans of either band, it’s a must. For the mildly curious or even the oblivious, it’s still a total blast.

Download: “Johnny Delusional,” “Police Encounters,” “Piss Off”

May 2015 reviews

Highly recommended this merry, merry month of May:

(reviewed earlier) Buffy Sainte-Marie, Mac McCaughan, Afiara Quartet + Skratch Bastid

(reviewed below) Boogat, Jean Leloup, Siskiyou, Young Guv

And as excited as I am that Shamir’s debut full-length is finally out and getting tons of deserved attention—like, say, this article I landed in Maclean’s—only half of Ratchet hits home for me.

Boogat – Neo-Reconquista (Maisonnette)

Boogat! Why this Mexican-Montreal MC doesn’t have an exclamation mark as part of his brand, I have no idea. He should. His electro mix of cumbia, reggae and pop is a perfect soundtrack for spring thaw, with rich percussion and horn sections and killer grooves, most co-programmed with Ghislain Poirier, a man who loves music from any part of the world that emphasizes bass. Jean Massicotte (Patrick Watson, Lhasa, Arthur H) produces. Boogat raps in Spanish, so I have no idea what’s going on here lyrically, but I do appreciate the title “Los Tabernakos.”

Boogat might hail from a city renowned for the more off-beat elements of electronic music, but Neo-Reconquista is slick enough that it could be a totally mainstream album—of course, assuming the Canadian mainstream would ever embrace Latino sounds that didn’t come filtered through an American pop star singing in English. (May 7)

Download: “Los Tabernakos,” “Los Presidentes” (feat. Heavy Sounds), “Londres” (feat. Pierre Kwenders)

Leonard Cohen – Can’t Forget (Sony)

No, Leonard, you’re right: we can’t forget. BECAUSE YOU KEEP REMINDING US.

This is Cohen’s third album in the last six months—the second of two live albums, and the Juno-winning Popular Problems, a collection of new songs. Not only that, this is the fourth live album since his 2008 comeback. Leonard Cohen now has more than half as many live albums (eight) as he does studio albums (13). The 80-year-old appears to be on a mission to re-record his entire catalogue before he shuffles off this mortal coil.

So here we have him souping up “Tower of Song,” offering two new lacklustre blues songs, covering country legend George Jones and Québécois icon Georges Dor, and dipping deep into his catalogue for “Joan of Arc” and a best-forgotten track from 1992’s The Future.

At least the cover art is clever. But that alone certainly won’t give even the most diehard fan a reason to tune in here. (May 21)

Download: “Choices,” “Tower of Song,” “La Manic” 

Jean Leloup – A Paradis City (Bonsound)

I don’t have to tell you that Quebec has its own, enormously popular francophone rock stars that are largely—if not completely—unknown in The Rest of Canada. If you’ve never heard of Jean Leloup, well, then, it’s a safe bet that there are no francophones or Québécois in your social circle.

Leloup has been around since 1989; he took a brief hiatus in the mid-2000s and this is his eighth album. He’s the kind of carefree, globe-trotting troubadour who tries his hand making documentaries about monkeys in Costa Rica for six months, just because. He’s not wrapped up in rock stardom, despite his iconic status in his home province.

That’s why A Paradis City is such a refreshing, welcoming record: Leloup exudes confidence and charisma, and writes anthemic songs that never succumb to bombast or weighty instrumentation—even when he calls in the choirs or string sections. Leloup makes it sound easy—hell, he even makes it look easy, by providing chord charts in the liner notes, and there are vocal-free karaoke versions up on his website. A Paradis City is the sound of a guy who could dial up the drama if he wanted to, but prefers more subtle strengths. There are quiet folk songs here, midtempo rockers, and a triumphant title track that shows, among other things, how much Sam Roberts learned from Leloup.

Jean Leloup is only playing seven shows with his band this year, five in Montreal and two in his native Quebec City. They’re not until November, and they’re all sold out. But just because he’s not going to come here and beg for anglo attention doesn’t mean we can be excused for ignoring him. (May 28)

Download: “Zone zéro,” “Petit papillon,” “Paradis City”

My Morning Jacket – The Waterfall (Universal)

Now that we’ve heard all of My Morning Jacket’s greatest tricks—the soaring majesty of Jim James’s voice, the epic guitar jams, the detours into new wave, reggae, and odes to black metal, all wrapped up in the haunting, reverb-drenched psychedelic folk-rock that started it all off 15 years ago—what can MMJ do in 2015 to impress us? Maybe they can start by impressing themselves.

For such a creative, curious band, MMJ sound oddly bored. With precious few exceptions, there’s an audible lethargy here, even on the ostensibly up-tempo tracks. From the vocal harmonies to the guitar grooves to the stadium-rock drums, so much of The Waterfall sounds like ’70s rock clichés that this band successfully avoided, or subverted, in the past. The only songs here I ever want to hear again are the ones that are the most stripped down, the ones that might as well by Jim James solo tracks, the ones where the power and glory of his band aren’t even in play.

That doesn’t bode well—but apparently the follow-up album is already finished and scheduled to come out in the next 12 months. (May 7)

Download: “Get the Point,” “Compound Fracture,” “Only Memories Remain”

Shamir – Ratchet (XL)

Music can disguise so much about ourselves. Certainly, we never know the nationality or gender or any other identifying factor of an instrumentalist. Vocals betray much more: accents, vocal range, regional tics. Then there are singers that sound utterly alien, beyond gender or geography or sexuality. Shamir Bailey, a 20-year-old phenom from Las Vegas, is one of those lovable aliens.

He’s been picked to click in 2015 ever since his 2014 indie EP Northtown built underground buzz; he’s now signed to a big label, has flashly, colourful videos (in one of which he’s remade into a muppet), and has been profiled by every magazine that matters. It’s not just because of his songs, which are a throwback to early house music—in part because he made his tracks on ancient equipment, and all drum machines and synths are programmed manually. No, it’s because his backstory is fascinating, as is his eclectic musical taste: Nina Simone, Taylor Swift and Mac DeMarco are equal touchstones for him.

Shamir seems unstoppable, and there is plenty of ammunition here to vault him in the mainstream, not unlike the way Lorde came from nowhere with her wise-beyond-her-years appeal. Lead single “On the Regular” is incredibly catchy, and proves that Shamir oozes charisma even while goofing off by trying his hand at rapping. Vegas is a poison love letter to his hometown. “Make a Scene” and “Hot Mess” are party anthems for bored youth. “Demon, if it wasn’t draped in a synth soundscape,” could be a killer country music ballad. (Shamir covered Lindi Ortega on his EP.)

That said, Shamir is best in small doses: half of Ratchet falls a bit flat, displaying that despite all his talent, he’s still young as a songwriter. But rest assured this is only the beginning of a long, eclectic career. (May 21)

Download: “On the Regular,” “Vegas,” “Demon”

Siskiyou – Nervous (Constellation)

Sure sounds nervous. Anxious, even. Worried. And yet determined to plough through whatever weird situation we all find ourselves in, surrounded by spooky soundscapes on this, the third album by Vancouver’s Siskiyou. Fronted by former Great Lake Swimmers drummer Colin Huebert (and featuring that band’s string player, Erik Arnesen), Siskiyou maintains a tension throughout Nervous, regardless of tempo or arrangement, major key or minor.

Opening track “Deserter” begins with a haunting children’s choir, leading into a bass line borrowed from The Cure’s “Fascination Street” before Huebert’s hushed vocals begin the verses. The tune gets more animated as it proceeds, with the choir singing off-beat shots, Colin Stetson’s baritone sax taking the solo, and ending with a ghostly coda with just Huebert and electric guitar.

Nervous was written after Huebert, who suffers from anxiety and panic attacks, was also diagnosed with a severe inner-ear condition. He took a songwriting workshop residency in the Yukon and crafted this material during a silent retreat. When he came back to Vancouver he rehearsed the material at low volume—even though this is not a quiet record; that explains the tension. The result sounds like an artist throwing everything they have into one final project, just in case it’s their last. He employed Stetson, Owen Pallett, Destroyer trumpeter JP Carter, and renowned producer/engineer Leon Taheny (Owen Pallett, Austra, Bruce Peninsula) to flesh out his grand sonic vision.

It makes for a great creation story—but the music itself is even better. (May 28)

Download: “Deserter,” “Wasted Genius,” “Violent Motion Pictures”

Patrick Watson – Love Songs for Robots (Secret City)

Fewer bells, fewer whistles, fewer bicycle wheels: that was the intention on Patrick Watson’s 2012 album Adventures In Your Own Backyard, where the Montreal singer and his band downplayed the novelty instrumentation that made them such a creative force, and focused on strong melodies, the kind Watson said he wanted to give him goosebumps every night on tour. Mission accomplished: the album was easily Watson’s finest, even if earlier works won big prizes and sold more records.

Love Songs for Robots is Watson’s first album without founding guitarist Simon Angell, who left to form Thus:Owls; newcomer Joe Grass might not conjure the otherworldly sounds Angell did, but he provides plenty of Lanois-esque texture and fluid leads. He brings the band closer to the classic Pink Floyd albums that their fellow Québécois love so much.

While that potentially disruptive lineup change has gone smoothly, Watson doesn’t meet his previous melodic standard here: much like his earlier albums, we must be content to hear his gorgeous voice and incredible band do all the heavy lifting. As a result, Love Songs For Robots is neither experimental enough to turn heads or pop enough to embed into our consciousness: it’s just there.

Five albums in, Patrick Watson is undoubtedly more compelling on stage than he is on record. But being the intensely curious fellow he is, there is always time for more mischief. (May 28)

Download: “Love Songs For Robots,” “Bollywood,” “Know That You Know”

  

Young Guv – Ripe 4 Luv (Slumberland)

Despite the fact that internationally acclaimed Toronto hardcore punk band F--ked Up has a growling frontman who rarely sings melodies with more than one note, the band’s songs are unusually catchy—no doubt a large part of their appeal outside a genre niche. So maybe it’s not that surprisingly that guitarist Ben Cook ghostwrites pop songs for mall-punk bands and mainstream pop artists—or so he says. It’s really not the least bit surprisingly when you hear these eight summery pop songs, most sung in a falsetto and with Teenage Fanclub harmonies, many of which sound like they belong on some 1982 AM-radio mix tape with Prince, Rick Springfield, Adam Ant and Lindsey Buckingham. Things take a slightly weirder turn on closing track Wrong Crowd, with its meandering saxophone and someone mumbling in French over a pseudo-Sade groove. Whether or not Cook does write songs for Taylor Swift, Maroon 5 and Kelly Clarkson—his claims don’t stand up to a cursory fact-check—Ripe 4 Luv shows that he most definitely should be, if he isn’t already. (May 28)

Download: “Crushing Sensation,” “Ripe For Love,” “Crawling Back to You”