Showing posts with label Bon Iver. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bon Iver. Show all posts

Monday, June 27, 2011

June '11 reviews

The following reviews appeared in the Kitchener-Waterloo Record and Guelph Mercury in the past month.



Matthew Barber – s/t (Outside)


Six albums into your career is an odd time for a self-titled album, but when you shack up at home with an eight-track and play every part on the album yourself, what else would you call it? Toronto singer/songwriter Matthew Barber breaks it down to bare bones on 10 songs that are mostly dedications to his beloved, either his family or his wife. “I sing because I’m a singer/ it’s what I do with my life,” he says. There’s nothing particularly weighty on the mind of this former philosophy student; the homespun music doesn’t demand any more. The only time his charm wears off is on the closing track, with an opening couplet that should never have left his pillow, never mind his bedroom: “Oh Lexi / you’re sexy/ your body lets me in.” Otherwise, these songs suggest that Barber is best when he’s straightforward and stripped down. (June 23)


Download: “Middle of a Dream,” “Blue Forever,” “Man in a Movie”



Bon Iver – Bon Iver, Bon Iver (Jagjaguwar)


Since For Emma Forever Ago, his breakthrough 2008 debut as Bon Iver, Justin Vernon has said that he doesn’t want to be just another guy with an acoustic guitar—which nonetheless was exactly what that album was. For its follow-up, he’s assembled a large band, including veteran pedal steel session player Greg Leisz and avant-garde saxophonist Colin Stetson, created electronic textures to intertwine with guitars and banjos, and layered his vocals extensively. It all adds up to otherworldly 22nd-century folk music, made all the more alien by Vernon’s own voices, which most of the time sound like a choir of Vocoders on helium. (Perhaps that’s why Kanye West is a big fan and sought him out as a collaborator.) While the album is certainly unique, and interesting in small doses, it gets really grating, really fast. The final test of patience is the closing track, “Beth/Rest,” which Vernon admits is an homage of sorts to ’80s singer/songwriter Bruce Hornsby—not even one of his studio albums, but perhaps a murky home demo, coloured with horribly dated electronic piano sounds. This doubly eponymous album is a bold move, but it’s bound to be a divisive one. (June 23)


Download: “Minnesota, WI,” “Hinnom, TX,” “Perth”



Booker T – The Road From Memphis (Anti)


Dennis Coffey – s/t (Strut/K7!)


Two soul legends deliver their best work in decades, if not their entire storied careers.


Booker T. Jones, the organ player best known for his classic track "Green Onions," has spent most of the last 30 years backing up people like Willie Nelson, Neil Young, and otherwise igniting few of the fireworks he did on his classic recordings with the MGs. He was last heard on an uninspiring album backed up by the Drive-By Truckers, the memory of which is entirely erased by this triumphant return.


It’s easy to credit the electrifying sound of The Road From Memphis to Jones’s collaborators: his backing band is the Roots, the producer is Gabe Roth from Sharon Jones and the Dap-Kings, and Dennis Coffey is on guitar (see below). Maybe it’s because of them that the 66-year-old Jones dances around the keys with the dexterity of his youth, but he sounds positively on fire, egged on in particular by drummer and co-producer ?uestlove. The material serves him well: a mix of original instrumentals, spritely versions of hits by Gnarls Barkley and Lauryn Hill, and contributing vocalists Jim James (My Morning Jacket), Sharon Jones, Matt Berninger (The National) all complement the mood perfectly. (Lou Reed, on the other hand, not so much.)


Guitarist Dennis Coffey is not as well-known as Booker T, but he’s played on dozens of hit records from his hometown of Detroit, including many Motown sessions. The opening guitar riff to the Temptations’ “Cloud 9”? That’s him. He also scored a major solo hit in 1971 with “Scorpio,” a favourite of hip-hop producers since the days of Public Enemy.


This self-titled album finds him revisiting some of his classic sessions, on tracks by Parliament, Funkadelic, Wilson Pickett and others, with help from local vocalists from Detroit’s soul and garage scene (including Mick Collins of the Dirtbombs) as well as hot R&B newcomer Mayer Hawthorne. Whereas with Booker T the material and the collaborators push the star to great height, here the same combination mostly allows Coffey to quietly do what he does best: sit in the background, write kick-ass arrangements, let the band as a whole do its thing while Coffey himself drives the beast with rhythm guitar that’s distorted, fuzzy, heavy on the wah pedal, and always extremely tasteful. There are few, if any, showboating solos here: Coffey isn’t that kind of player, although he certainly has the chops to do it. The original compositions are just as vibrant as the classics.


There’s no mistaking Booker T’s album as the work of anybody but, and it’s guaranteed to please any old soul. Coffey, on the other hand, is the surprise: that anyone still makes hard-edged soul like this with a large band, a psychedelic edge and such colourful arrangements is an unexpected delight.

The only thing better than the arrival of these two records would be news that they’re touring together. (Note: they're not, though Coffey checks into the Horseshoe in Toronto on July 8.) (June 2)


Download Booker T: “Walking Papers,” “The Road From Memphis,” “Rent Party”


Download Dennis Coffey: “I’ll Bet You,” “7th Galaxy,” “Space Traveller”



The Burning Hell – Flux Capacitor (Weewerk)

A “flux capacitor” is the key element of the time machine used in Back to the Future. The album named after it finds songwriter Mathias Kom reflecting on his odd life, his childhood obsessions and his wandering nature (he’s lived in Winnipeg, Peterborough, Whitehorse and now St. John’s). Kom has a wry wit and conversational vocals, which means much of this material is more entertaining as a friend telling you funny stories, rather than actual songs. It would all be little more than an inside joke—and arguably a lot of it is—if Kom wasn’t so engaging and charismatic, which is why the autobiographical “My Name is Mathias” is an album highlight, though “Nostalgia” is probably more fun live than it is here.


His band—a new group of St. John’s players, not the Peterborough crew from previous albums—boasts plenty of baritone saxophone, clarinets, violins and trombones to bolster Kom’s ukulele backdrop and baritone vocals, and Flux Capacitor has more orchestral arrangements than the organized chaos of Kom’s previous line-up. Though it’s not his strongest work, there’s still plenty of proof that Kom is a unique and original songwriter, capable of using an Albert Einstein quote in song that indirectly sums up Kom’s own work here: “We are all equally foolish before God, and equally wise.” (June 9)


Download: “My Name is Mathias,” “Report Card,” “Pirates”



Mark Davis – Eliminate the Toxins (Saved by Radio)


Mark Davis is kind of a morose guy. On the opening track of his third solo album—the previous two having dealt with the death of a spouse—he decries the god who robbed him of his beloved; later on he tells someone who has lost their father that there are “so many ways / to wake up dead.” And yet he insists, “Waste no tears on me, sad-eyed lady.”


And nor should you. Despite its often dour details, the album takes its titular advice to heart, finding hope and inspiration amidst the emotional wreckage. Davis is the rare artist who can channel catharsis from morbid material, whose empathetic voice offers hope and embodies survival.


It helps that he writes immediately affecting songs, with a melodic gift worthy of any of the greats; every single song here sounds like a modern classic. He draws from obvious influences—“Go to Ground” provides an aural image of Neil Young hanging out in Berlin with David Bowie and Brian Eno in 1978—and yet the album is a decidedly modern take on psychedelic roots rock, one where vocals run through a Leslie speaker sound just as alien as the drum machines and synthesizers that colour what are, at their essence, straightforward folk songs. Even all of those tools are only slight distractions; the core instrumentation wouldn’t sound out of place on any Blue Rodeo record: rich acoustic guitars, 12-string electric guitars, banjos, harmonicas and even whistling.


Davis successfully combines the comfort food of Canadiana roots rock with spooky sonic spellcasting in ways that few artists other than Daniel Lanois even attempt. That he does it by throwing chunky rock songs and pop hooks into the mix is even more impressive. Perfect production, timeless songs—what more do you want? Eliminate the Toxins may be full of ghosts, but you’ll want these songs to haunt you for a long, long time. (June 16)


Download: “Waste No Tears,” “A Good One,” “Let the World Know Where You Are”



Dengue Fever – Cannibal Courtship (Fantasy)


All cross-cultural mash-ups are cannibalistic in nature. In this case, Cambodian musicians of the ’60s produced a unique regional take on American rock and pop music of the day. Thirty years later, a group of L.A. musicians, fronted by a Cambodian expatriate from a popular musical family there, take that Cambodian hybrid and make it into modern American music with traces of east and west African influences. “You’re just another stamp in my passport,” sings vocalist Chhom Nimol, but she and her band don’t feel the same way about the musicians in their record collections.


Dengue Fever know that there are two ways to approach this material: with an absurdist sense of fun—like on “Cement Slippers,” the goofy first single and duet between guitarist Zac Holtzman and Nimol—or with serious reverence to all elements of the amalgam. Three albums into their career, Dengue Fever lean more toward the latter, though the mystery stops with a thud when modern rock guitars weigh down a chorus, as on the title track or “Family Business.” There are also some outright cringe-worthy moments, like “2012” (“There are so many predictions!”). But Nimol is captivating throughout, and Holtzman effectively wields his new instrument, a double-neck guitar—one neck is a Fender Jazzmaster, the other an electric version of the Cambodian instrument called the chapey.


Dengue Fever have this corner of cross-cultural collision all to themselves, and make cannibalism seem terribly tasty. (June 30)


Download: “Cement Slippers,” “Sister in the Radio,” “Kiss of the Bufo Alvarius”



Fucked Up – David Comes to Life (Matador)


I was one of the few unconvinced that this Toronto band’s 2008 album The Chemistry of Common Life was somehow a watershed moment for hardcore punk, despite the fact it won the Polaris Prize, got them signed to one of the most-respected American indie labels, and garnered attention from plenty of mainstream press and even public radio both here and in the U.S. To an aggressive genre born and ossified in the early ’80s, Fucked Up brought broad ambition, flutes, violins, female vocals and other distractions to counteract Damian Abraham’s visceral one-note growl. But on the album itself, somewhere underneath the 70 layers of guitar tracks, they forgot how to be a great punk band (which you can hear them be on the 2009 compilation Couple Tracks); Common Life was as bloated as the prog rock that punk was created to slay in the first place.


Now comes what the band claims is a rock opera. At 18 tracks and 70 minutes, Fucked Up prove once again that they don’t lack for ambition. And the first third of this album sounds like it’s paid off: the production is 10 times better than on Common Life, with the guitars roaring out of the speakers, Abraham comfortably placed in the mix instead of sounding like the guy who’s always belching loudly at the party, and songs that match fist-pumping punk energy with, well, the idea of a rock opera that The Who pioneered in the late ’60s.


Yet the album loses steam quickly after that, and not just because Abraham sounds monotonous on a good day, and not because no one in the world can possibly comprehend the narrative, which apparently has something to do with love lost and found while living in Thatcher’s England. After the initial burst of inspiration on the opening tracks, the music doesn’t function as punk, not as prog, not as pop, and certainly not as rock opera. The production—especially the guitar tones—is the only consistent strength here, and it’s curious how close the band comes to sounding like U2 at times, which surely was not what they were going for. But who knows? (June 16)


Download: “Queen of Hearts,” “The Other Shoe,” “Turn the Season”



Handsome Furs – Sound Kapital (Sub Pop)


Handsome Furs’ Dan Boeckner and Alexei Perry have spent the last two years touring almost every corner of the world, especially the ones that few other Canadian bands dare to tread: Montenegro? Burma? Lebanon? Check, check, and check. They’ve learned that the unifying global music is not rock’n’roll—it’s the synth pop that blares out of basement clubs, taxicabs and storefronts the world over. And so Boeckner sets his guitar aside for most of Sound Kapital, and joins Perry in programming the synths and drum machines, making the combination of equally joyous, abrasive and raucous music that the likes of Kraftwerk, Suicide, Skinny Puppy and even Depeche Mode could never have visualized.


Anyone who loved his now-disbanded group Wolf Parade knows that Boeckner writes killer songs and is a powerful howler of a rock singer. In Handsome Furs, he still highlights those strengths while he and Perry dive deep into sound sculpting. Their 2009 album Face Control featured some of the most delicious guitar sounds put to tape in recent memory, contrasted with harsh synths and deep drum machines; here the guitar is only a texture, taking a back seat to icy Europop synths that Lady Gaga would love to get her hands on. (The album was mixed in Finland and Berlin, for whatever that’s worth.)


Sound Kapital isn’t as jam-packed with hooks and riffs as Face Control was, but it’s a different, darker beast. Boeckner takes more pointedly political turns than ever before, singing in a voice of the disembodied and disenfranchised about the “damage of the Western world,” vowing to “never be repatriated,” railing about how “you don’t serve the people” and asking “what about us?”


Part of what Boeckner finds fascinating about the far-flung places he visits is the sense of renewal, of forging a new history instead of being trapped in the prism of the past: “No nostalgia on the stereo / No hits because there’s no radio / no replacement / a thousand lonely kids making noise in the basement.” Even if Handsome Furs—Boeckner and Perry grew up in Lake Cowichan, B.C., and Elora, Ont., respectively—don’t happen to come play for some of those thousands of lonely kids in their hometown, Sound Kapital itself will make the world seem a lot less lonely. (June 30)


Download: “What About Us,” “Cheap Music,” “When I Get Back”



Junior Boys – It’s All True (Domino)


There’s nothing like failure, real or perceived, to motivate the creation of greater work. Junior Boys’ bandleader Jeremy Greenspan was apparently so distraught at the muted reaction to the electronic group’s last album—which, granted, was far from their strongest work—that for two months he set up shop in Shanghai, the other side of the world from his home base in Hamilton, and started writing and recording new material as a form of therapy.


Even without that back story, it’s evident from the titles that Greenspan is undergoing some kind of mid-career crisis: “Second Chance,” “A Truly Happy Ending,” “Kick the Can,” “You’ll Improve Me.” The music suggests he’s coming out on top.


Junior Boys have always been trapped between sad-sack pop songwriting, new wave revivalism and current electronic trends; they were discovered, after all, by Steve Goodman, aka Kode 9 and the man who launched the now-ubiquitous British electronic subgenre known as dubstep. Greenspan seems willing to let the pop part of the equation slide a bit; while still melodic, he’s diving deeper into sounds and surrendering to the grooves, especially on the euphoric nine-minute closing track “Banana Ripple,” easily the most buoyant and deliberate disco move on any Junior Boys album, the sound of Greenspan dancing his blues away into the night. (June 23)


Download: “Itchy Fingers,” “Playtime,” “Banana Ripple”



Kevin Kane – The Home Version (independent)


Since the breakup of his ’80s band the Grapes of Wrath, songwriter Kevin Kane has lived largely under the radar, and not entirely by his own design. A series of fine solo records went largely unnoticed, which is reason enough for him to revisit his rich catalogue (especially now that the venerable West Coast performer has relocated to Toronto). The Home Version is just Kane and his guitar, reaching back to the first Grapes of Wrath recording (“Misunderstanding”) right up to his last album, How to Build a Lighthouse. While the lush harmonies he’s known for are sadly lacking, the intimacy of the recording—which among other things allows you to focus on his fine acoustic guitar playing—makes up for it. (June 23)


Download: “Misunderstanding,” “Days,” “Last to Know”



Thurston Moore – Demolished Thoughts (Matador)


Sonic Youth are such a prolific band, both as a unit and with umpteen side projects, that very little attention is ever paid to one member’s solo record anymore—especially because no one can remember the last time the band produced something worth getting excited about.


Yet here is guitarist Thurston Moore’s acoustic solo record, produced by Beck and laced with eerie violin and harp passages. Simply by unplugging, Moore—who helped rewrite the rules of rock guitar in the late ’80s and early ’90s—sounds refreshed and engaged. Whether he’s drawing from Nick Drake, Indian folk influences, or trademarks of his own oeuvre, Moore pulls between pop and the avant-garde just as he always has. The result is certainly not a singer/songwriter record, but an enchanting surprise from a veteran reinventing himself. (June 2)


Download: “Blood Never Lies,” “Mina Loy,” “Illuminine”



My Morning Jacket – Circuital (ATO/Maple)


My Morning Jacket are one of the great American rock bands of the last decade, a reputation largely gained through their live shows. It’s there that one can completely appreciate the full-throat projection of Jim James’s voice, the sweeping dynamics that can coax lullabies into epic Southern rock anthems, the spaciousness provided by the band’s dabbling in reggae and electronics. Expect to hear all of that on the live box set they’re planning on releasing shortly.


In the studio, My Morning Jacket is not an easy band to pin down. While that can occasionally lead them down some unusual paths—like the Prince-inspired falsetto funk of the last studio album, 2008’s Evil Urges—that experimentation provides ample rewards more often than not. (Though in the case of Evil Urges, it certainly didn’t—which makes this the first good MMJ album in five long years.)


And so in an inconsistent discography, Circuital stands as one of their best albums to date, one that combines everything they’ve ever done well with subtle rhythmic approaches that could make a case for them being the American Radiohead, only with a stronger interest in pop-song structure. (The title track even sounds a bit like Radiohead’s “Creep,” as covered by Tom Petty’s Heartbreakers with Daniel Lanois on lead guitar—just in case you’ve ever wondered what that would sound like.)


There are times when things threaten to get a bit loopy—like the female choir singing woah-oh-ohs throughout a Tom Jones-like number called “Holdin’ On to Black Metal” (yes, it’s about the genre of music)—but Circuital is both remarkably consistent and constantly surprising. Pedal steel guitar and Rhodes piano are always at the forefront, with the associated country and soul influences permeating through every track, no matter where else the rhythm section is leading the band. James’s voice ties everything together: he’s becoming a more effective singer at every end of his range, not just the high notes.


As good as Circuital is, no doubt it shines even brighter on stage. My Morning Jacket play the Kool Haus in Toronto on July 11. (June 9)


Download: “Circuital,” “Victory Dance,” “First Light”



Snailhouse – Sentimental Gentleman (White Whale)


Montreal’s Michael Feuerstack “writes the songs that make the grown men cry,” he sings in the title track of his eighth album. It’s one of several moments here of self-reflection on his role as a melancholy man, as a musician who’s always on the outside looking in, as a self-aware songwriter who cuts to the heart of every situation with a well-placed couplet like, “I want the headaches that you bring / I want the painkillers, too.”


Following up his must-own masterpiece Lies on the Prize is no small task; instead, Feuerstack focuses on bringing out the strengths in his most recent backing band, who make Snailhouse gel as a real group for perhaps the first time ever, instead of simply being a vehicle for Feuerstack’s songs. He still pulls in some favours from his all-star friend pool; including appearances from Katie Moore of Socalled and Pietro Amato of Bell Orchestre and the Luyas; Arcade Fire’s Jeremy Gara mixed the album. Yet any Snailhouse album is ultimately about Feuerstack’s lyrical ability to make you chuckle and cry simultaneously and unsuspectingly—or, in one extreme case, dance “on the ledge with your heads in your hand like some solitary conga line.”


He’s one of Canada’s finest songwriters, and sadly one of its most unsung. If you’re a fan of sentimental gentlemen in general, you’ll fall for this Sentimental Gentleman in particular. (June 23)


Download: “Daydream,” “Sentimental Gentleman,” “Great Storytellers”



Tyler the Creator – Goblin (XL)


It’s an odd coincidence that this album came out the same month that Stanley Kubrick’s film version of A Clockwork Orange celebrated its 40th anniversary. Tyler the Creator, the ringleader of a massively popular L.A. hip-hop collective Odd Future Wolf Gang Kill Them All—who went from being an underground online sensation to the subject of 10,000-word essays in the New Yorker—makes his mainstream debut with an album drenched in nihilism, misogyny and ultraviolent imagery that makes A Clockwork Orange seem antiquated and quaint.


Tyler frames the album as a dialogue with his therapist; and so instead of an all-out shockfest, Goblin is a whiny orgy of self-loathing where the protagonist claims he doesn’t have the guts to kill himself, hates being famous, blames all his trouble on women and his absent father, and has violent sexual fantasies while masturbating and doing drugs. Occasionally he attempts to be somewhat sensitive on tracks imaginatively titled “She” or “Her”; the former promises to deliver eight bullets to the subject of his stalking affection if she dares to turn him down after hearing such a charming come-on.


So why are we supposed to care? If Tyler had an ounce of charisma, he might at the very least be amusing. But after countless disclaimers about how he’s not a role model, how no one should do what he says (i.e. “Kill people, burn s---, f--- school,” goes the chorus of “Radical”), he comes off as a poser who doesn’t even have the guts to embrace his more-loathesome-than-thou persona. Is Tyler supposed to embody our darkest thoughts? Is he a trickster kicking against all social convention? Is he just a jackass?


He claims, “I’m f---in’ radical, I’m motherf---in’ radical.” Just as anyone who walks around saying “I’m so cool” is obviously the uncoolest person in the world, Tyler the Creator is little more than a 19-year-old boy who needs some kind of therapy—preferably not the kind conducted in public and on record. (June 16)


Download: “Yonkers,” “Nightmare,” “She”



Rave On Buddy Holly – Various Artists (Fantasy)


Buddy Holly is famous for three things: a) his biggest hit was “That’ll Be the Day (That I Die)”; b) he died in a plane crash at 22 with two other pop stars in 1959; c) Don McLean had a baffling #1 hit in 1971 with a song ostensibly about Holly’s death, “American Pie.”


Holly’s discography goes much deeper than this morbid trivia, of course. Despite the brevity of his career, almost every track he ever recorded was a classic—and there’s plenty of evidence of that on this 19-track collection, where even the duds at least have a great song beneath the bizarre performance (I’m looking at you, Lou Reed’s “Peggy Sue”).


The inspired guest list includes Nick Lowe, Patti Smith, Fiona Apple, My Morning Jacket and more, most of whom play it relatively straight—sometimes too straight (Justin Townes Earle) or flat (Zooey Deschanel of She & Him being the worst offender). Cee-Lo, the Black Keys and Florence and the Machine all reinvent a ’50s production aesthetic in their own modern ways, combining elements of rockabilly, bossa nova and New Orleans jazz.


Julian Casablancas of the Strokes, on the other hand, chooses to channel mid-period Billy Idol, for better or worse. And throughout “It’s So Easy,” Paul McCartney howls almost unintelligently like a manic southern rock radio DJ, like he’s suddenly trying to convince everyone that he was the really wigged out Beatle (hey kids, remember “Helter Skelter”?!). And Kid Rock is shockingly tasteful, using only bass, gospel backing vocals, handclaps and a horn section to deliver a soulful version of “Well All Right.”


This tribute was assembled to commemorate what would have been Holly’s 75th birthday. If he left this legacy and songbook at the age of 22, one can only imagine what else he would have got up to in the past 53 years. (June 30)


Download: Cee-Lo Green – “You’re So Square (Baby I Don’t Care),” Florence and the Machine – “Not Fade Away,” Kid Rock – “Well All Right”



The Weeknd – House of Balloons (independent)


It’s rare for an album to arrive out of nowhere and turn an entire genre on its head. That’s exactly what’s happened with Toronto R&B artist The Weeknd (not to be confused with the ’90s indie rock band from London, Ontario, who spelled “weekend” properly). Little is known about the people behind The Weeknd, other than that the singer is a 20-year-old named Abel Tesfaye, with help from the occasional producer (including Martin “Doc” McKinney, who’s worked with Esthero, Santigold and many more).


The Weeknd is a strange bridge between modern R&B conventions—the smooth, Autotuned vocals, the melismatic flourishes, the R. Kelly-ish plainspoken anti-poetic take on cooing come-ons—with the dark, spooky corners of dubstep, the sinister edge of Massive Attack and the inventiveness of Prince at his strangest. For that reason, it’s likely to infuriate fans of both sides: it’s far too weird for mainstream tastes, and yet the vocals are anathema for anyone who thinks T-Pain is responsible for all the evils of modern music. Tellingly, both Drake and Adele are huge fans and supporters.


Like Drake, The Weeknd specialize in self-doubt mixed with decadence, except that Tesfaye, though juvenile, is nowhere near as loathsome a lyricist as Drake (though he’s occasionally just as juvenile). He’s also a much better singer and the music is far superior—spacious and haunting where Drake just sounds empty.


The inventiveness heard here has justly fascinated critics around the world, making The Weeknd one of the biggest buzz bands of the last few months—and two more albums are expected by years’ end, as well as a collaboration with Drake. Whether they prove to be a one-off fluke or the beginning of a new wave of R&B remains to be seen, but House of Balloons—even with all its flaws—is daring enough to be considered a game-changer. (June 2)


Download: The entire album is available for free at the band’s website, the-weeknd.com

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Colin Stetson


When Colin Stetson straps on his bass saxophone, he looks like he’s girding up for war. This is the bass saxophone we’re talking about, not the baritone; the bass saxophone is the musical instrument that most resembles a rocket launcher.

Stetson’s solo performances—which is what he does when he’s not performing with Arcade Fire, Laurie Anderson, Antibalas, or as a member of Bell Orchestre—can be an all-out assault, involving sheets of sound ripped from the bell of his sax, woven together with relentless arpeggios—all delivered via circular breathing.


Stetson, who grew up in Michigan and lived in Brooklyn and San Francisco before moving to Montreal, is not the kind of guy to stand on a street corner and serenade you with “Harlem Nocturne.” He’s less interested in melody than he is in every acoustical property possibly found on his saxophone: the percussive clicks and clacks; the non-notatable sounds of wind moving through it; the resonance of a room; the sound of his voice amplified through the saxophone, with or without the reed in play.


All of that makes him a skilled player, and anyone who witnessed an early solo show or heard his 2008 debut album, New History of Warfare Vol. 1, could attest. And his capacity for subtlety is part of the reason why the likes of Tom Waits (Alice), Bon Iver (the upcoming album), and TV on the Radio (Return to Cookie Mountain) have all enlisted him for studio recordings.


His new album, Judges: New History of Warfare Vol. 2, is a different beast entirely. Compositionally and sonically superior to its predecessor, Judges finds Stetson moving beyond the obvious—dare I say—gimmick of his solo show into the realm of emotionally engaging and enrapturing material.


He claims there’s an overarching narrative running through both albums, something about the societal structures of a group of shipwrecked sailors and blind horses rigged with automatic weapons. This will all one day make it into a graphic novel. Thankfully, he didn’t ask guest vocalists Anderson or Shara Worden (My Brightest Diamond) to provide explicit exposition; instead, they’re almost distractions from the pleasure of getting lost inside his very private soundworld. Stetson does everything else himself, and records it live: there are no loops, overdubs or other trickery, other than some strategic mic placement.


I didn’t feel like asking him about the sci-fi narrative; I think those things are best left to a listener’s imagination.


Judges was released on Tuesday by Montreal's Constellation Records. Stetson performs with Laurie Anderson on Jimmy Fallon tonight.


Colin Stetson

February 6, 2011

Locale: phone from his home in Montreal


In performance, there’s an aspect of it that’s very meditative, there are parts that are ominous, parts that are ecstatic, and part of it is an all-out assault at times. What do you hope people take away from it when they’re witnessing it?

That was pretty good, what you just said. For me, that sums up a lot of my process, my experience of it. There is the ecstatic, but there is also the element of physical suffering, which then gets into the mind, because there’s pain involved. There’s a weird balance you get when you’re in certain states and dealing with oxygen deprivation. It’s like running a marathon or some kind of physical feat, where there is a lot of satisfaction but a lot of mixed emotion. What I hope people get from it is any one of those things that they feel causes a reaction. I feel like music is there to tell stories and cause a reaction. If they are there and it affects them in any way—emotionally, physically or otherwise—then that’s good.


It’s very hard to ignore. It is a physical experience to witness it—though obviously not as physical as you actually doing it. It’s not music to chat at the bar over.

No, that’s not my intention.


But to play devil’s advocate: someone at the bar might say, ‘Why do I want to listen to a guy practice arpeggios and his breathing technique?’

If that’s all that people are seeing then I’d prefer that they all left. It’s not a geek show—although I understand that there’s an element of that, the spectacle of seeing a guy sweat and turn red and do freaky shit.


Like weightlifting, really.

But the point of it is the music. I’m not doing these things for the sake of doing these things, of saying ‘look what I can do.’ Those are the things I have to do to make that music, and I hope people are hearing and experiencing and being moved by that music. If they’re not engaged in it musically in any way, there’d be no reason for them to be at the bar still.


I’ve seen you perform twice, but I can’t recall if you ever actually explain what’s happening on stage, that there’s no pedals involved.

I rarely say anything about that. Sometimes people will yell out things or ask a question and I’ll say something about it. Mostly I find the only reason for doing that would be to let everyone know that I’m working hard up there. Musically, I don’t think it changes anything, so it would be an awkward thing to have to say. Sometimes people will go to the soundman and ask them about what pedals I was using. But even when people are told, they don’t believe me, so I don’t care anymore. It’s noted on the records, but there’s a certain lack of imagination, I think. I’ve had interviewers say, “Well, your record says there are no loops or overdubs, but really, what’s your process?” Why do you think I would lie about that?


It is so uncommon, especially with so many shortcuts available these days, for someone to invest in the physicality of such a thing. How much does mic placement play a role on stage?

It depends on the size of the show. I prefer to do acoustic shows, resonant spaces like churches, warehouses, concert halls, places that accept a lot of sound and actually enhance it. But that’s not often the case, and I’m usually playing through PAs. Then I use an extremely stripped-down pile of mics: an internal mic, which is key for getting the fundamental low end of the instruments; I use a clip-on external mic, which gives the overall shine of the bell; I sometimes use a throat contact mic and contact mic on the instrument for percussion.

But I rarely use all that; it’s too many wires to deal with. When the show is acoustic, all those things are in play: you’ll hear the percussion, you’ll hear the vocalization. The only reason I do more miking for large shows is the further away people are, the more the PA is giving off the sound, and I want more things to be represented. A lot of things are lost when you only have one tiny microphone providing a snapshot of the overall instrument. But there’s never a way to capture things the way I want to during the recording process.


Part of what makes this record come alive compared to the first one is the mix, the sense of space.

Everything was bigger with this record. The first one was my first attempt at this notion of multi-miking and creating a surrealist reality within the context of the recording medium. The room was much smaller; we only used hover mics, no contact mics or internal mics. The Hotel 2 Tango [Constellation’s in-house studio, where the new album was made] is a massive space, so there were a lot of things that could be miked.


When did you decide to devote yourself to solo performance rather than forming your own band?

I’ve been doing occasional solo performances since my mid-20s, but they were more in the genre of free jazz and improv. I was dealing with some of these themes and techniques, but in much more of a stream of consciousness, improvised way. The shows resembled some of the things I was doing now, but over the years they developed into through composed pieces.

It was probably around 2005 that I started to focus on the solo pieces, I think because I was really busy in New York, playing with tons of bands, and having a hard time feeling like I had a focus. Me and my best friend Stuart Bogie [of Antibalas], who is an amazing sax player in New York City, his advice was to strip things down and start from a place with just a couple of projects. So I quit a bunch of things and stopped the hustle, and started focusing on the solo project and just a couple of key projects.


When did circular breathing become an essential part of what you do?

I’ve been doing that since I was 15. When I was in high school, I was a classical player primarily. My teacher at the time, Christopher Creviston, he was a phenomenal classical player and the big inspiration for me getting more involved in music. One of the things he taught me right away was circular breathing. His reasoning was that a lot of the pieces we played were transcriptions of string pieces. String players don’t need to breathe, so they don’t have to make the same choices we do because of breath. He used it as a means to overcome that. Also, in the teenage classical scene when you’re playing competitions, it’s flashy and it’s impressive and it wins you shit! ‘Use this and you’ll win.’ It totally worked. I got a scholarship to college because of that.


Forgive my ignorance, but is it something anybody can learn, or do some people have a natural capacity for it?

No, it’s very easy to do. The actual act of doing it is very simple. It’s like riding a bike. As soon as your brain overcomes the natural unwillingness to allow your body to do it, when you do it once, then you have it. The process of breathing in while breathing out is simple. What is hard is doing it while doing other shit—the muscle control of everything while you’re doing the intake/outtake.


And then there’s the amount of breath required to play a bass saxophone, too.

You need to send up a lot of air up that instrument. When you’re doing the intake/outtake, you have to keep an enormous amount of pressure on there to keep up the volume you want. You use a lot of diaphragm and face muscle. The technique itself is really secondary. The only thing that has come into play for me is that now I have the ability to breathe in and out through my nose while breathing out through my mouth, which allows me to play softly and with more nuance. It’s an ongoing process, like anything else physical. People in yoga or running talk about this, how it’s this path you get on and you never stop learning.


The bass saxophone itself, there’s an inherent physicality to it whether you’re circular breathing or not. What drew you to it? Where did you find one?

I’d wanted to play it since I was in college. We had one in university that nobody ever played, and I occasionally took it out for a spin. I played a lot of baritone in college, and always loved the low end of things more. I appreciated the depth and breadth of overtone that you can obtain, and the power.

But it’s hard to find good bass saxophones, and when you do, they’re really expensive. I found one on eBay in 2005, out of the blue. It was a beautiful 100-year-old instrument going for a really low price. I couldn’t figure out what could be wrong with it, and neither could my repairman. So I was playing this ridiculous show called the Jammies—which is like the Grammys for jam-band music—in the most awesome band ever, which was Medeski Martin and Wood as the rhythm section, with Antibalas horn section, and Burning Spear and Sinead O’Connor singing. It was so amazing, so out there…


See, I saw all those people on your resumé, but I didn’t realize that was all at just one gig.

I know, that’s where you cheat with your resumé! So that night we were just about to go on and my eBay auction was coming up, and my friend and I just sat there hitting refresh. And we won; I got it a few weeks later. That was one of those dark moments when you finally get the thing you’ve wanted your whole life, and then you open it up and you start playing it and you realize that it’s fucking hard and you sound like shit on it. I always assumed it was just the same but a bit bigger—but it’s a lot bigger.


It’s about twice the size of a baritone, isn’t it?

Yeah, by the sheer size of the pipe and the width of it, yeah. It took a lot of training to get to a place where I could start making music with it.


After first seeing you live several years ago, I wasn’t sure if I wanted to buy the record. It was months later that I did. Hearing this new one, it’s obvious that there’s more composition and emotional resonance than something experienced only in the moment live. When I was watching it I wondered if it was something that only existed in the moment; the new CD answers that question for me.

They are two completely different experiences. When you present live music, all the things that are in play make a unique experience: you’re physically there, the sound is in the air and is touching your body. You’re experiencing it with your physiology, with your understanding, and with everyone else who is there. When you’re listening to a record, none of those things are in play. I don’t think you should approach it the same way. That’s why I try to make a unique experience out of this medium, so that it is not in any way trying to emulate the live experience, because you’ll always fall flat if you try to do that. I want to create something equally moving and informative. I come back to Haruki Murakami, who is my favourite writer, who achieves something I try to do with these records, which is to present this world as fact. I try to make a record like a Haruki Murakami novel.


Could you elaborate? What do you mean, creating a world with accepted parameters with an understanding of what happens within that world?

He’s not writing science fiction, but he’s not writing in this reality. His reality is his own, and you just accept it as you read along. You don’t accept it in a way that you’re envisioning another world or a different time or whatever. It’s just: this is the story, and this is its reality. There is a matter-of-factness that he demands and creates in a reader. It was the most impressive thing for me, so I’ve always wanted to achieve the same thing with these records, with this music. I’ve even ripped off some titles from his writing.


Maybe you should get him to appear on your next one. Why get Laurie Anderson or Shara Worden on this record? What role do their voices play on this record?

I always wanted to have human speech as an element; it’s the one thing the music is lacking. I wanted there to be some kind of abstract narrative, not in any way literal or having a vocalist for all these pieces.

With the first record, it was done quickly and in a haphazard way. We ended up using samples of talks by Buckminster Fuller. When I was first thinking about making these records, the recording process was the idea of the geodesic dome. We were going to take the three-dimensional sound, the reality of what’s happening in the studio, and capture it with as many mics as we can. We’d call that the dome, and then unfold it and fold it up again in a new way, creating a new reality from all the snapshots that we took. I grabbed some things that he said that I thought were creating this abstract narrative.

I had been working with Laurie for a little while, for the whole course of writing this new record, and I asked her if she wanted to do something. Her words and her voice are magic; there’s really nobody with her ability to, again, with one sentence can draw you into her world, something all of her creation. So I jumped at the opportunity for her to contribute, to be that voice. Shara I had been working with in The Long Count, and we’d talked about doing something together anyway. This record is inspired by a lot of American pre-war gospel music, and a lot of the writing was based on work songs, to have that inherent sadness and transcendence. I found a song that I thought would be perfect for the two of us to do in this way.


What was it you said you worked with her on? The Long Count?

Yes, Aaron and Bryce Dessner from the National teamed up with the Deal sisters and wrote this thing based on the Mayan calendar and its creation myth. It was a whole thing about twins. I was part of the group that played the music for it, and did some of my solo stuff in the context of it, and Shara was the main voice in it. She has this otherworldly haunting voice. Having her voice represent this part of this record helped create this element of a lost space, a lost people hunting, that was isolated geographically and through time and evolved in its own way, unfettered by outside power.


Laurie Anderson’s words here—was that a text she had lying around, or did you ask her to write something on the theme of the record?

I gave her very little to go on, and what I ended up giving her was that the album was about isolation, with themes of fear and transcendence. She just went ahead and riffed. The second to last song on the record, with both Shara and Laurie on it, was something that I had asked them both to do simultaneously, independent of one another, and I got both of theirs back on the same day. I pressed play on them both at the same time and I freaked out. They seemed to read each other’s minds, which was awesome.


What else is on your plate now? I know you were performing new works with Laurie Anderson in the fall, post-Homeland. What was she doing?

All last year we were doing her stage show Delusions. I think we’re done with that at this point, and she wants to do smaller musical projects. The two of us are talking about collaborating on some more stuff. I think we’re playing on Jimmy Fallon in a couple of weeks. [Tonight, actually, Thursday, February 24.]


Is she recording Delusions?

I don’t think so. Some of the stuff from Delusions was on Homeland, so that would be somewhat redundant. But I wouldn’t rule it out. So I’ll be working with her, I’ll be doing solo stuff, I might be playing again with Sway Machinery, which is a band I’ve been in for years. And come June I start to rehearse with Bon Iver and we’re going to hit the road in July for that new release.


What’s the lineup of that band?

It’s the original four, and then the four of us who orchestrated this new record, and one other, and that’s the touring band.


Anything happening with Bell Orchestre in the near future? Are you still a part of it?
Yeah, whenever it happens. I’m sure it will, but I’ve had no word yet. It’s a thing that’s very difficult to function when Arcade Fire is so busy. So when they finish in September or something—I’m not sure when they’re done—I’m sure Bell Orchestre will do something.


Will you be in Toronto any time soon?
Yeah, I’m playing the jazz festival. I forget the venue, but it’s on June 28.


I understand you just got back from Europe with Godspeed.

Yes, and then a solo show in New York and a show in Quebec City with Tim Hecker.


I just had a baby two months ago and Tim Hecker is perfect baby-whisperer music. Whereas your album, on the other hand, he likes to cry along with.

I’ve heard that before, actually. Old friends of mine brought their newborn to a San Francisco show a couple of years ago, and the baby liked to cry along in tune.